Should we ban football and other sports with a high likelihood of injury?

Medpagetoday has a survey about football and whether or not it should be banned. Should it be banned? Here is the link: http://www.medpagetoday.com/Surveys/ Maybe you should register your vote.

I know there was an article in the paper in the past few weeks about a prominent medical examiner who suggested football be banned for those under 18 years. (Here is a link to the abc news report: http://abcnews.go.com/Health/chicago-bears-football-player-dave-duersons-suicide-renews/story?id=13003593 )

I’ve blogged before about the use of protection (mouthguards) and their role in prevention of injury (here is the link –it was a while ago…. http://mentalnotesbyjoanne.blogspot.com/2009/09/sports-and-risks-of-concussion.html --you will see some comments from one of my very knowledgeable and bright students as well). I am not clear however on the remaining risks despite use of much protective equipment.

Here is an interesting article –written in 1977 – by a chiropractor who suggested way back then that there should be a switch from football to soccer. He made the suggestion based on his experience treating up to 1/3 of those playing in his local football league… http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2378736/pdf/canfamphys00306-0030.pdf His rationale is based on not only the often serious spinal, ligament and muscular injuries he treated, but his belief that soccer is a better cardiovascular conditioning sport.

Some of the comments on the medpagesurvey also suggest that youth are encouraged to ‘bulk up’ for the team, potentially adding cardiovascular risk to the list of other health hazards.

I must admit, other than being an occasional football spectator, I know little about the sport and its culture. As an outsider it does seem to be one of the sports where brute strength and physical contact are the norm, and the crowds seem to love to see the physical contact and a great brawl… (although other sports also have these qualities).

There is also a culture in athletics today where children are involved in both school and recreational athletic programs. If a child has talent, they can belong to an ‘elite’ team. It is quite an industry today that I don’t think existed in the past. I think it is common also for parents to partially live out their own athletic dreams in the performance of their child. At what point is society going too far? At a recent athletic competition I was very aware of the wrist, ankle and other splints being worn by the athletes. I’ve watched children ‘shake off’ an injury and continue in competition… is this a good practice?

I think we have much better data today about the problem of injury and long term health consequences in sports. Here is a blog written by a neurologist, who speaks to the long term effects of hitting your head that does not result in a concussion. The result is Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE) – previously known as dementia pugilistica. http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/neuro-atheism/201102/ban-football As Dr. Weisman so aptly notes, we are not measuring the regular head blows that occur in this or any contact sport. So we underestimate exposure all the time! A positive currently is that we are much more focused on the identification and treatment of concussion– a step in the right direction, but one that does not necessarily resolve the problem.

As a scientist and a parent, I am concerned about sports injury. I am deeply disturbed that many children enter adulthood with chronic injuries that they will live with forever. In the case of head injury, my concerns are of course deepened. Football is not alone… many sports share very high risk of injury and athletes, parents, and coaches must consider and reconsider this dilemma.